This Can't Be Love: The Witty Classic by Rodgers and Hart
In the world of musical theater, few songwriting partnerships are as legendary as Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart. Among their vast catalog of hits, "This Can't Be Love" stands out as a clever subversion of the romantic tropes common in the late 1930s. Rather than leaning into the drama of heartbreak or longing, the song takes a humorous look at the feeling of being healthy and happy while in love.
Origins in The Boys from Syracuse
First published in 1938, "This Can't Be Love" was written as a show tune for the musical The Boys from Syracuse. In the original production, the song was performed by Eddie Albert and Marcy Westcott. The piece is celebrated for its lyrical wit, specifically how it pokes fun at the traditional depiction of love in popular music.
While many songs of the era described love as a series of malignant symptoms—such as sleeplessness or emotional turmoil—the lyrics of this track argue the opposite. The central premise is captured in the line, "This can't be love because I feel so well," suggesting that the absence of suffering is a surprising way to experience romance.
[ไม่มีภาพประกอบ]Chart Success and Popular Recordings
Beyond the Broadway stage, the song transitioned into a popular hit for several big bands and orchestras. Between late 1938 and early 1939, two versions gained significant traction on the charts.
- Horace Heidt: The orchestra's version featured vocals by Larry Cotton.
- Benny Goodman: The renowned swing leader recorded a version featuring vocals by Martha Tilton.
Key Facts
- Composer: Richard Rodgers
- Lyricist: Lorenz Hart
- Year Published: 1938
- Original Musical: The Boys from Syracuse
- Original Performers: Eddie Albert and Marcy Westcott
Song Overview
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Genre | Show Tune / Popular Song |
| Release Year | 1938 |
| Key Theme | Satire of romantic clichés |
| Notable Artists | Benny Goodman, Horace Heidt |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who wrote the song "This Can't Be Love"?
The song was composed by Richard Rodgers with lyrics written by Lorenz Hart.
Which musical was this song originally from?
It was written for the 1938 musical The Boys from Syracuse.
What is the meaning behind the lyrics?
The lyrics satirize the common trope that love must feel like a sickness or a struggle, claiming instead that the singer cannot be in love because they feel too healthy and well.
Who were the original performers of the song?
The song was originally sung by Eddie Albert and Marcy Westcott in the stage production.
Which orchestras made the song a hit in the late 1930s?
The orchestras of Horace Heidt (with Larry Cotton) and Benny Goodman (with Martha Tilton) both had hit versions of the song in late 1938 and early 1939.